Yamana Gold Inc vs. Kinross Gold Corporation: Which Gold Miner is a Better Bet?

Should you buy Yamana Gold Inc (TSX:YRI)(NYSE:AUY) or Kinross Gold Corporation (TSX:K)(NYSE:KGC) in 2015?

| More on:
The Motley Fool

Over the past two years, shares of Yamana Gold Inc (TSX:YRI)(NYSE:AUY) and Kinross Gold Corporation (TSX:ABX)(NYSE:ABX) have fallen 51% and 67% respectively. The running joke in the industry is that they split 2:1 the hard way.

But if you like going against the crowd, the turmoil in the mining industry could be seen as the perfect buying opportunity. The only question, which stock is a better bet for investors?

Certainly, Yamana and Kinross are both levered bets on higher gold prices. However, there are also some key differences that need to be considered. Let’s see how the two companies stack up on a range of measures.

Safety: The words ‘safe gold miner’ almost sounds like an oxymoron. Yamana’s portfolio includes properties throughout Central and South America. There is some real geopolitical risk here. That said, Kinross’s two largest mines are located in Russia. With all of the tension between that country and the west, investors have completely written off these properties. Winner: Yamana.

Valuation: However, you could argue that the market is overreacting. Today, the entire Kinross Corporation (including equity and debt minus cash) is worth $5.3 billion. By comparison, Eldorado Gold, whose production totals less than a third of Kinross’, is worth $5.7 billion. Goldcorp, which produces roughly the same amount of gold as Kinross, is worth more than $21 billion. That makes the stock look absurdly cheap. Winner: Kinross.

Operating costs: Low gold prices have left miners with little wiggle room to pay off debt or other expenses, let alone reward shareholders with dividends. That said, Kinross can haul an ounce of gold out of the ground for about US$750, versus today’s spot price of US$1,200 per oz. Yamana, in contrast, needs gold prices above US$850 per oz to remain above cash flow breakeven. Winner: Kinross.

Earnings growth: Based on analyst estimates compiled by Reuters, Kinross earnings per share are expected to shrink 17% over the next five years. By comparison, production at Yamana is soaring. The company is expected to deliver 15% annual EPS growth over the same period. Winner: Yamana.

Dividend yield: No contest here. Yamana has still managed to eke out small dividends to shareholders and yields about 1.4%. Kinross, in contrast, was forced to cut its dividend completely. So if you’re looking for current income, then Yamana is your first choice. Winner: Yamana.

Debt load: When the tide goes out, you get to see who’s swimming naked. And that has definitely been the case in the mining sector. Companies took out huge portions of debt to fund their expansions during the boom years. That said, both Kinross and Yamana have always managed their balance sheets conservatively. However, Yamana has the smallest debt load of the two. Winner: Yamana.

And the results are in…

Look, both of these stocks are risky investments. However, Yamana has the better means to weather today’s low gold prices. If you’re looking for exposure to precious metals, then this company is your best bet.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Robert Baillieul has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

todder holds a gold bar
Metals and Mining Stocks

Canadian Mining Stocks: Buy, Sell or Hold?

Investing in quality gold mining stocks that trade at a reasonable valuation could help you beat the TSX index over…

Read more »

People walk into a dark underground mine.
Metals and Mining Stocks

Is First Quantum Minerals Stock a Buy?

Let's dive into whether First Quantum Minerals (TSX:FM) is worth buying at current levels, or if investors should sit this…

Read more »

nugget gold
Metals and Mining Stocks

Competitive? Beat the Market With These 2 Dividend-Paying Growth Gems

Investors looking to beat the market buying dividend stocks right now need to focus on this right sectors. Here are…

Read more »

nugget gold
Metals and Mining Stocks

A Canadian Billionaire Investor Sold Micron Stock and Bought This TSX Company Instead

Prem Watsa focuses on value over short-term growth.

Read more »

Concept of multiple streams of income
Metals and Mining Stocks

Is Franco-Nevada Stock a Buy for Its 1.2% Dividend Yield?

Gold royalty stocks represent a niche in the precious metals industry. They have different dynamics from mining stocks.

Read more »

todder holds a gold bar
Metals and Mining Stocks

The 1 Mining Stock Canadians Should Buy and Hold Forever

Newmont is a gold mining stock that trades at a cheap valuation, making it a top investment choice for those…

Read more »

Metals and Mining Stocks

Top Canadian Gold Stocks to Buy Now

Canadian gold mining stocks such as Barrick Gold and Kinross Gold are two top investments in October 2024.

Read more »

todder holds a gold bar
Stocks for Beginners

Is the Worst Over for SSR Mining Stock?

SRR Mining stock has been rising higher after recent earnings performance that made a bit of a comeback. So is…

Read more »