Gerry Schwartz or Heather Reisman: Whose Stock Should You Buy Now?

While it might seem obvious to those on Bay Street, in recent quarters, Indigo Books and Music Inc. (TSX:IDG) has made this question much tougher to answer.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

For those who don’t follow the personal lives of high-powered business executives, you might not realize that Gerry Schwartz and Heather Reisman, CEOs of Onex Corporation (TSX:OCX) and Indigo Books and Music Inc. (TSX:IDG), respectively, are married to each other.

And up until recently, Schwartz’s private equity firm was the stock to own of the two—hands down.

But almost out of nowhere, Reisman and her team have managed to gain some traction with their transformation of Indigo into something other than music and books. Gifts, technology, and kid’s toys have become a much bigger piece of the total revenue pie—and a much tastier one at that.

Investors have taken notice, pushing Indigo’s stock to a 52-week high of $18.26 midway through Wednesday’s trading. The last time it hit $18? Over 16 years ago in January 2000. Back then there actually was music in the stores. It’s been a long haul for the 67-year-old native of Montreal.

That’s not to say the comeback is complete. There are still some problems in its business that need sorting out.

The first issue is Indigo’s small-format stores. While the performance has been more than satisfactory—they had Q3 2015 same-store sales growth of 13.4%—there just isn’t a need to keep them around, and this is evidenced by the four store closures in 2015.

Add to this the fact that online revenues in the third quarter were just $2.3 million less than the $56.4 million generated by 126 small-format stores; in essence, you are paying rent on 126 doors with average revenue of approximately $1 million per year, or about 15% of what each superstore generates on an annual basis.

The small stores have to go.

Secondly, online sales, while growing at a double-digit clip—17.9% in the third quarter—they still only represent 14% of overall revenue. In 2011 online sales accounted for 9% of Indigo’s overall revenue. Is growing your online business as a percentage of sales by 500 basis points a good showing? I don’t think so.

The third problem for Indigo is profitability. Through the first nine months of fiscal 2015, its adjusted EBITDA was 7% of revenue; in fiscal 2010 it was 7.5%. It’s done little to reduce the cost of running its business. That needs to improve. By comparison, Barnes & Noble’s EBITDA for its retail group in 2015 was 7.8% of its US$4.1 billion in revenue.

As for Onex, it’s got a lot more moving parts, making it a little tougher to assess how its business is doing. Private equity is become very popular in recent years, so it’s no surprise that Onex’s stock is up 15.5% on an annualized basis over the past five years through May 17 compared to 1.0% for the S&P/TSX 60. Down 10.3% year-to-date, its seven-year winning streak could come to an end if it doesn’t pick up the pace in the second half of the year.

Onex tries to meet two long-term goals for its business. First, it seeks to grow its capital per share by 15% per year. Over the past five years, it’s achieved just 9% per year due to higher than usual cash balance and a mark-to-market decrease in the value of its collateralized debt obligations. So, this number is always changing. The second goal is to grow its fee-generating assets by 10% annually. It delivered 11% annual growth over the past five years, so it’s batting 50%.

If Amazon didn’t exist, the choice for me would be Indigo because it’s a miracle it’s making money given how big a hole it dug for itself over the last few years. However, as soon as Onex puts its cash to work, its goals will likely be met and then some.

Long term, I’d go with Gerry Schwartz and Onex. But it’s not an easy choice by any means.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned. David Gardner owns shares of Amazon.com. The Motley Fool owns shares of Amazon.com.

More on Investing

3 colorful arrows racing straight up on a black background.
Investing

1 Canadian Stock Ready to Surge Into 2025

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) stock is a sleeping dividend giant that may be about to wake up.

Read more »

Tractor spraying a field of wheat
Investing

Is Nutrien Stock a Buy for its 4.7% Dividend Yield?

Nutrien (TSX:NTR) is a well-known defensive commodities play. But is this stock worth buying for its dividend yield alone?

Read more »

Happy shoppers look at a cellphone.
Tech Stocks

So You Own Shopify Stock: Is it Still a Good Investment?

Shopify (TSX:SHOP) stock has had a run, but there's still room to the upside.

Read more »

Paper Canadian currency of various denominations
Investing

The Best Stocks to Invest $2,000 in Right Now

Do you have some extra cash to spare? Here are three Canadian stocks to add to your watch list today.

Read more »

tsx today
Stock Market

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Friday, November 22

Continued gains in gold, oil, and natural gas prices could give the commodity-focused TSX benchmark a boost at the opening…

Read more »

Train cars pass over trestle bridge in the mountains
Dividend Stocks

Is CNR Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2025?

Can CNR stock continue its long-term outperformance into 2025 and beyond? Let's explore whether now is a good time to…

Read more »

engineer at wind farm
Energy Stocks

Invest $20,000 in This Dividend Stock for $100 in Monthly Passive Income

This dividend stock has it all – a strong outlook, monthly income, and even more to consider buying today.

Read more »

Hourglass and stock price chart
Stock Market

It’s Not Too Late: Invest in These TSX Growth Stocks Now

Solid fundamentals of these top TSX growth stocks could help them maintain strong upward momentum in the years to come.

Read more »