S&P/TSX Composite versus S&P/TSX 60: Is it Time to Ride the Bigger Index?

History suggests now is the time to consider moving from the iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (TSX:XIU) to the iShares S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index Fund (TSX:XIC).

| More on:
The Motley Fool

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s premium investing services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

Should your investments be focused or diversified? Big or small? These are some of the questions facing investors as they ponder which S&P/TSX index to use to passively track Canada’s stock market.

One has 248 stocks; the other has 60. One is meant is to cover the entire Canadian stock market; the other invests in 60 of Canada’s largest companies. Both are passive investments that will help you reach your retirement goals.

And both will let you down at times.

So, which ETF should you buy?

Should you buy the iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (TSX:XIU) or the iShares S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index Fund (TSX:XIC)? Both aren’t going to break the bank when it comes to fees—0.06% for XIC and 0.18% for XIU—so you can rest easy knowing your hard-earned savings aren’t being frittered away by cushy salaries for active managers.

A look back at the annual total return of both ETFs since 2006 shows an interesting pattern.

Index performance: 2006 through November 15, 2016

Year S&P/TSX 60 (XIU) S&P/TSX Composite (XIC)
2006 19.12% 17.09%
2007 10.84% 9.56%
2008 -31.09% -33.34%
2009 31.31% 34.55%
2010 13.84% 17.42%
2011 -9.31% -8.79%
2012 7.92% 7.01%
2013 13.07% 12.46%
2014 11.94% 10.95%
2015 -7.81% -8.62%
2016 16.61% 16.27%

Source: Morningstar

The S&P/TSX 60 did better than the S&P/TSX Composite between 2006 and 2008. Then their roles reversed with the S&P/TSX Composite outperforming its smaller sibling between 2009 and 2011.

Now, with the S&P/TSX 60 up 34 basis points year-to-date on the S&P/TSX Composite Index with six weeks left in the year, the ETF based on the smaller group of stocks appears to be heading to a fifth consecutive year bettering its big brother.

But we should look at how the two ETFs have performed over the long haul. With the S&P/TSX 60 handily beating the S&P/TSX Composite in what could be eight out of 11 years, the S&P/TSX 60 should be the better performer.

Drumroll, please.

The cumulative total return of the S&P/TSX Composite Index from December 30, 2005, to November 15, 2016, is 31.9%. The cumulative return of the S&P/TSX 60 over the same period … 37.9%—600 basis points higher. Case closed.

Not so fast.

Yes, in absolute terms, the S&P/TSX 60 has outperformed the S&P/TSX Composite Index, but consider the pattern that sits before us.

Should the S&P/TSX Composite Index pass the S&P/TSX 60 in the remaining weeks of the year to take back the performance title—don’t forget about regression to the mean—it could be year one in a four-year streak to match the S&P/TSX 60’s run from 2012. If the S&P/TSX Composite Index doesn’t squeak out a victory, I believe it could be the start of a five-year run.

Best-case scenario and I’m right, you’ll get better returns on your passive investment while paying lower fees; worst-case scenario, the S&P/TSX Composite Index trails the S&P/TSX 60 by several hundred basis points over the course of four or five years. That works out to $234 on a $10,000 bet.

But, if the S&P/TSX Composite Index comes through as I think it will, you’ll gain far more than $234 dollars.

It’s your call.

Should you invest $1,000 in IGM Financial right now?

Before you buy stock in IGM Financial, consider this:

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor Canada analyst team just identified what they believe are the Top Stocks for 2025 and Beyond for investors to buy now… and IGM Financial wasn’t one of them. The Top Stocks that made the cut could potentially produce monster returns in the coming years.

Consider MercadoLibre, which we first recommended on January 8, 2014 ... if you invested $1,000 in the “eBay of Latin America” at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $20,697.16!*

Stock Advisor Canada provides investors with an easy-to-follow blueprint for success, including guidance on building a portfolio, regular updates from analysts, and two new stock picks each month – one from Canada and one from the U.S. The Stock Advisor Canada service has outperformed the return of S&P/TSX Composite Index by 29 percentage points since 2013*.

See the Top Stocks * Returns as of 3/20/25

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned.

Confidently Navigate Market Volatility: Claim Your Free Report!

Feeling uneasy about the ups and downs of the stock market lately? You’re not alone. At The Motley Fool Canada, we get it — and we’re here to help. We’ve crafted an essential guide designed to help you through these uncertain times: "5-Step Checklist: How to Prepare Your Portfolio for Volatility."

Don't miss out on this opportunity for peace of mind. Just click below to learn how to receive your complimentary report today!

Get Our Free Report Today

More on Investing

An investor uses a tablet
Stocks for Beginners

The Smartest Canadian Stock to Buy With $250 Right Now

Are you looking for the smartest Canadian stock to buy right now? Consider this gem and avoid market volatility.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian REIT Stocks to Buy and Hold for the Next Quarter-Century

These three Canadian REITs trade cheaply and are highly reliable, making them some of the best stocks you can buy…

Read more »

Electricity transmission towers with orange glowing wires against night sky
Investing

Fortis Just Might Be the Best Canadian Dividend Stock to Buy in April

Let's dive into a few reasons why Canadian utility giant Fortis (TSX:FTS) still looks like a screaming buy heading into…

Read more »

A train passes Morant's curve in Banff National Park in the Canadian Rockies.
Dividend Stocks

1 Practically Perfect Canadian Stock Down 24% to Buy Now and Hold for Life!

CNR stock is a top Canadian stock for investors, especially with shares down on the TSX today.

Read more »

a man relaxes with his feet on a pile of books
Investing

Got $7,000? How I’d Spread It Across 5 Blue-Chip Stocks for an Investing Foundation

Spreading $7,000 across these five blue-chip stocks provides a solid foundation for long-term financial success.

Read more »

The letters AI glowing on a circuit board processor.
Tech Stocks

How I’d Allocate $10,000 to AI Stocks in Today’s Market

Shopify (TSX:SHOP) is one of Canada's most compelling AI stocks.

Read more »

The TFSA is a powerful savings vehicle for Canadians who are saving for retirement.
Retirement

Top Canadian Value Stocks I’d Hold in My TFSA for the Next Decade

These Canadian value stocks have significant growth potential and will enhance your TFSA portfolio’s return in the long run.

Read more »

Canada national flag waving in wind on clear day
Dividend Stocks

The Best Canadian Stocks to Buy Right Away With $30,000

If you have $30,000 you're willing to invest, these are some of the first Canadian stocks to consider on your…

Read more »