How Low Can Home Capital Group Inc. Go?

Home Capital Group Inc. (TSX:HCG) is facing an Ontario Securities Commission enforcement action following allegations it had improperly disclosed a number of mortgage applications. Here’s why Home Capital Group may fall faster than expected.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

My recent article spoke of a long-term short play for Home Capital Group Inc. (TSX:HCG) for reasons completely separate from the recent announcement this past week that the company is facing Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) enforcement action following allegations the company had improperly disclosed a significant number of mortgage applications containing falsified income information on loan applications.

Since my article was published, Home Capital Group’s stock is down approximately 13%, and speculation abounds that this company’s stock price may take a larger hit in the long term due to potentially increased headwinds for the mortgage-lending company.

I’ll take a look at new reasons why Home Capital Group may fall faster than expected.

The allegations

The OSC has alleged that Home Capital Group “failed to meet its continuous disclosure obligations” and subsequently served the company with an enforcement action late Friday afternoon. The enforcement action pertains to a disclosure made by Home Capital Group in 2015 that brokers and brokerages representing the firm had falsified income information on mortgage applications in 2014 and 2015.

The parties responsible were suspended by Home Capital Group, and the company’s stock price took a 21% hit in July 2015 after mortgage origination numbers came in lower than expected relating to the suspension.

Home Capital Group asserts that it believes it has satisfied all disclosure requirements, and the company will be given the chance to respond the enforcement action before the OSC decides whether or not to commence proceedings.

The bigger, more pressing issue

Analysts are less concerned with the OSC enforcement action than they are with the possibility of a class-action lawsuit, as previous disclosure failures have led to such suits in the past. An analyst from National Bank of Canada points to a 2009 class-action lawsuit brought against Manulife Financial Corp. in which the firm settled the $1 billion lawsuit for $69 million.

General agreement is that the proposed economic penalties imposed by the OSC on Home Capital Group would be manageable; however, a class-action suit or other further actions brought against Home Capital Group could yield much bigger problems for the mortgage lender in the long term.

What is likely to happen, regardless of whether OSC proceedings commence or a class-action lawsuit is brought against Home Capital Group, is that the market will assign a higher risk premium to this company. In addition to the legal risks associated with the most recent announcement, the firm engages in a significant portfolio of non-prime and sub-prime lending which, while carrying higher yields, carries higher risk — risk the market may be forced to price in more heavily into the company’s stock price.

In any case, this is one firm I remain extremely cautious of.

Stay Foolish, my friends.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Chris MacDonald has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of HOME CAPITAL GROUP INC.

More on Bank Stocks

Paper Canadian currency of various denominations
Bank Stocks

1 Magnificent Canadian Dividend Stock Down 28% to Buy and Hold for Decades

This top Canadian dividend stock is underperforming its large peers this year, but a turnaround could be on the horizon.

Read more »

data analyze research
Bank Stocks

Is BMO Stock a Buy for its 4.8% Dividend Yield?

Canadians are looking to cut back, and BMO stock is on board. But it could also be a top stock…

Read more »

Investor reading the newspaper
Bank Stocks

Is Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce Stock a Good Buy?

CIBC is a TSX bank stock that has delivered marketing-beating gains to shareholders in the last two decades. Is the…

Read more »

Man data analyze
Bank Stocks

Where Will TD Stock Be in 5 Years?

TD stock is a good consideration for a 5.2% dividend on the recent dip. It provides upside potential, too, but…

Read more »

customer uses bank ATM
Bank Stocks

These 3 Canadian Bank Stocks Are Next in Line to Pop

Let's dive into three Canadian bank stocks that look well-positioned to continue to soar over the long term.

Read more »

a person looks out a window into a cityscape
Stocks for Beginners

Bank of Montreal vs. RBC: Which Canadian Bank Stock is the Better Buy?

Earnings season is upon us, and the Canadian banks will be reporting before you know it. So which of these…

Read more »

stocks climbing green bull market
Bank Stocks

2 Undervalued Canadian Bank Stocks to Buy Now

Here's why investing in undervalued Canadian bank stocks such as BMO and EQB can help you beat the TSX Index.

Read more »

money goes up and down in balance
Bank Stocks

Is National Bank of Canada Stock a Buy for Its 3.4% Dividend Yield?

National Bank of Canada stock has surged over 1,000% in the past two decades, if we adjust for dividend reinvestments.

Read more »