Investing in IPOs Can Make You Broke

The IPOs of Aritzia Inc. (TSX:ATZ), Real Matters Inc. (TSX:REAL), and Roots Corporation (TSX:ROOT) are forgettable TSX IPOs. The stocks have not delivered the desired gains to investors since their IPOs.

| More on:

Initial public offerings (IPOs) are opportunities for investors to win big in the stock market. However, not all IPOs are successful. Some can make you flat broke. So, beware before taking on a position. Here are some of the market debutantes that went bust during and after the IPO.

Out of fashion

Vancouver clothing brand Aritzia (TSX:ATZ) debuted on the TSX on October 3, 2016. The IPO price was set at $16 and closed at $17.71 on the first day. The company was able to raise total gross proceeds of $400 million. Aritzia’s IPO was Canada’s largest in 2016 and happened during a lean IPO period.

From an investor standpoint, the IPO wasn’t exactly a success. If you were to look at the current price of $17.64, you can conclude the stock hasn’t really taken flight. The highest the price could go was $19.79, and not once was the $20 mark reached. Had I invested $1,000 on Aritzia’s IPO, my money would be worth $996.04 today.

Market observers raised some red flags prior to Aritzia’s IPO. Besides being oversubscribed, the dual-class structure was a risk factor. They said new shareholders would have no voting power to elect directors, auditors, and participate in succession planning. The power rests with the company’s founder and existing shareholders only.

No staying power

Investors had high hopes for Ontario-based Real Matters (TSX:REAL). The company is the leading player in the network management services platform sector for the mortgage and insurance industries. About 90% of the business is in the U.S. retail estate market, which is perhaps the biggest asset class in the world.

The real estate software company priced the shares at $13 but finished at $12.89 on May 11, 2017, which is the opening day. Real Matters’s CEO Jason Smith boasted that it was the largest technology IPO on the TSX in 10 years. Smith was correct as the company was able to raise a total of $157 million.

But the unexpected occurred in 2018. On December 31, 2018, the stock closed at $3.30. As of July 26, 2019, the price has climbed to $7.99. However, it’s still 38.5% worse than the IPO price.

Roots did not grow

On October 25, 2017, Roots (TSX:ROOT) went public and started trading on the TSX. The Canadian apparel company debuted at a time when competition in the retail market was very stiff. The IPO price was set at $12 but opened lower at $11.50. It was just the beginning of a nightmare.

Roots closed the first day of trading at $10, or 16.67% lower than the IPO price. Even if the company has the advantage of owning a brand, it wasn’t enough to generate investor interest. The total amount raised was $200 million.

Roots’s IPO was a disaster and was unceremoniously tagged as the second-worst first-day performance of 10 IPOs over $100 million in 2017. At present, the price is down to $3.44, which is 65.6% lower than the closing price on market debut.  You can picture the extreme disappointment of those who invested in Roots — an IPO that had no chance of growing.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Tech Stocks

A person uses and AI chat bot
Tech Stocks

AI Where No One’s Looking: Seize Growth in These Canadian Stocks Before the Market Catches Up

Beyond flashy headlines about generative AI, these two Canadian AI stocks could deliver strong returns for investors who are willing…

Read more »

Data center servers IT workers
Tech Stocks

Better Buy: Shopify Stock or Constellation Software?

Let's dive into whether Shopify (TSX:SHOP) or Constellation Software (TSX:CSU) are the better options for growth investors in this current…

Read more »

nvidia headquarters with nvidia sign in front
Tech Stocks

Nvidia Just Delivered a Beat-and-Raise Quarter. There’s 1 Red Flag Investors Shouldn’t Ignore.

The chipmaker continued to benefit from robust demand for artificial intelligence (AI). But can it last?

Read more »

GettyImages-1473086836
Tech Stocks

Why Super Micro Computer Stock Is Soaring Today

The volatile stock is getting a boost from Nvidia.

Read more »

Snowflake logo in snowflake office on wall_snowflake-1
Tech Stocks

Here’s Why Snowflake Stock Skyrocketed Today

Shares of the data company are up 32% for the day.

Read more »

man touching magnifying glass button on floating search bar internet google search engine
Tech Stocks

Why Alphabet Stock Was Sliding Today

The parent company of Google is facing heat from U.S. regulators.

Read more »

chart reflected in eyeglass lenses
Tech Stocks

Top Canadian AI Stocks to Watch in 2025

Celestica (TSX:CLS) stock and another Canadian AI stock are worth watching closely this holiday season.

Read more »

Nvidia Voyager Headquarters
Tech Stocks

Why Nvidia Stock Rallied (Again) on Tuesday

The chipmaker is expected to report earnings this evening.

Read more »