Suncor Stock (TSX:SU): A Value Stock Worth Buying or a Value Trap?

Suncor Energy stock is poised for a rebound as the company makes important changes to address weak operational performance.

| More on:

Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX:SU)(NYSE:SU) is Canada’s leading integrated energy giant. It had a market capitalization of $58 billion and almost $12 billion in operating cash flow in 2021. Trading at a price-to-earnings multiple of 6.8 times and a price-to-cash flow multiple of a mere 3.8 times, there’s no question that Suncor is a value stock.

The uncertainty lies in whether this is a golden opportunity or a value trap. Is it a sitting duck waiting for rescue or ruin?

A value stock or a bargain

Oil and gas prices continue to show strength. Today, oil is trading comfortably above $90 a barrel. And natural gas is fast approaching $10. These prices are a far cry from last year’s levels, up 34% and 116% respectively. This has translated into soaring profits and cash flows for Suncor, which in turn, has translated into soaring dividends for Suncor shareholders.

But in any good story, we eventually find a snag – something that puts the brakes on. In this case, it’s Suncor’s safety record, which is unacceptable. We cannot put a number on this. It’s just there in the background, muddying up the waters and leaving a bad taste in our mouths.

How could this once prime example of excellence have fallen so hard? And in the most profound way? Were we just not paying attention? Since 2014, Suncor has had 12 workplace deaths. According to activist investor Elliott Investment Management, this is more than all of Suncor’s peers combined.  

Suncor energy stock price value stock

In the last five years, Suncor’s dividend has grown by almost 50%. Its operating cash flows have soared 30%. Yet, Suncor has seen its stock price rise only 14%. Clearly, there’s something here that’s not being reflected in the numbers.

Looking back at Suncor Energy vs CNQ stock

Suncor’s safety record, its diversified business, and the implications of being in the fossil fuels business are all possible reasons why Suncor stock is underperforming. But the bottom line is that Suncor’s peers are doing better. Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. (TSX:CNQ)(NYSE:CNQ), for example, has seen its operating cash flow double in the last five years. Similarly, its dividend has risen 170%. Moreover, CNQ stock is up 92% during this time period.

cnq stock

Like Suncor, Canadian Natural Resources is in the fossil fuels business. This has not stopped its stock price from soaring. So maybe Suncor has underperformed due to the fact that its operations consist of downstream (refining) as well as upstream (production). This diversity is a good thing, as it results in more stable cash flows and earnings. This means that in difficult industry conditions, Suncor will be sheltered. Likewise, in booming industry conditions, Suncor stock will probably not have as much upside as the stock of pure producers like CNQ.

The last thing to consider is Suncor’s operational performance. Given the number of fatalities at its sites, we have to question the company’s “safety versus profit” decisions. I agree with Elliot Investment when it says that a good operator will not have to sacrifice safety for operational excellence. It’s a good thing that there’s been a shakeup of Suncor management. It seems that it’s time for changes – on a management and operational level.

The upside is within reach

Suncor’s new CEO has been tasked with fixing the company’s safety and operational performance. New management at all levels will focus on safety, and building a new foundation for operations. To this end, the company is in the process of deploying collision avoidance and fatigue management technologies. These technologies are used globally in mining, but this is the first time they’ll be deployed in oil sands.

The oil and gas industry is still booming. With new management’s focus on operational and safety improvements, there’s strong potential here. This will be the catalyst. And with Suncor Energy stock trading in value territory, I think there’s room for significant upside.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Karen Thomas owns shares of Canadian Natural Resources Ltd. The Motley Fool recommends CDN NATURAL RES.

More on Dividend Stocks

monthly desk calendar
Dividend Stocks

This 7.8% Dividend Stock Pays Out Every Month

Not all monthly dividend stocks are created equal. And this top stock is certainly a strong choice for passive income.

Read more »

A worker gives a business presentation.
Dividend Stocks

Is TMX Group Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2025?

TMX Group (TSX:X) stock has been a consistent wealth-builder, generating 4,630% in total returns since 2002. Should you buy, sell,…

Read more »

Man data analyze
Dividend Stocks

2 Deeply Undervalued Dividend Stocks to Buy in November

Here are two stocks that I view as deeply undervalued this November.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

The 2 Best Canadian Blue-Chip Stocks to Buy Now

Blue-chip stocks can be some of the best stocks to have in any portfolio. But when they're trending upwards, investors…

Read more »

Canadian dollars in a magnifying glass
Dividend Stocks

Here Are My Top 3 Dividend Stocks to Buy Now

These top dividends stocks have consistently paid and increased their dividends. Further, this trend will continue.

Read more »

dividends can compound over time
Dividend Stocks

Want a 7% Yield? The 3 TSX Stocks to Buy Today

These TSX stocks are offering high yields of over 7%, making them attractive for investors seeking steady passive income.

Read more »

how to save money
Dividend Stocks

The Smartest Dividend Stocks to Buy With $200 Right Now

These smartest dividend stocks can consistently pay and increase their dividends in the coming years, irrespective of the macro uncertainty.

Read more »

Electricity transmission towers with orange glowing wires against night sky
Dividend Stocks

3 Utility Stocks That Are Smart Buys for Canadians in November

These utility stocks benefit from regulated businesses and generate predictable cash flows that support higher dividend payouts.

Read more »