GICs vs. High-Yield Stocks: What’s the Better Buy for a TFSA?

TC Energy (TSX:TRP) is a high-yield Canadian dividend stock that may have more to offer than high-rate GICs.

| More on:

GICs (Guaranteed Investment Certificates) really do seem like a no-brainer investment for any Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA) right about now, with the recent August wave of stock market volatility and a potential recession that could hit at some point over the next 12-18 months.

Indeed, recessions entail quite a bit of pain for stock investors. However, many pundits see the next downturn as mild in nature. And though recessions are never ideal for stocks, the past year of volatility may have already priced in more than a mild contraction in the Canadian economy.

It can be a scary time to buy stocks, especially as we sail into September — a month that’s seen some pretty ugly trading days, historically!

In any case, smart TFSA investors know that timing the market is a bad idea and that long-term investing is key to putting one on the fast track to a nice retirement. In an era where inflation is running hot, I’d argue younger TFSA investors should stick with some of the higher-yielding stocks rather than settle for GICs.

GICs and risk-on dividend stocks? That’s the big question for TFSA investors!

Now, GIC rates are pretty good, whether we’re talking about the big banks or the smaller financial institutions (think Oaken Financial). But at today’s slate of valuations, I still find dividend stocks (especially those with high yields) to be capable of greater total returns over the next two to three years.

GICs are free from risk and offer north of 5%. That said, some high-yield dividend stocks offer more than 5% dividend yields and a considerable amount of upside potential. Of course, you’ll need to take risks. But if you’re young and venturesome, some risks are worth taking!

Today, the pipeline space isn’t just rich with yield; it’s also pretty rich with value. And you don’t really need to dig into the mid-cap universe to uncover stocks that offer next-level value and dividends.

TC Energy: High risk, higher reward?

Take shares of TC Energy (TSX:TRP), which is in a rut alongside the broader midstream energy industry. The company is down more than 35% from its high, thanks in part to a slew of industry and macro headwinds. At multi-year lows of around $48 and change per share, the yield has swollen to an unprecedented 7.74%.

Indeed, any dividend yield close to 8% ought to be viewed with skepticism. Nobody wants to hold a stock that’s in for a dividend cut! Fortunately, I don’t think TC Energy will slash its payout anytime soon.

The company has issues, but TC Energy’s dividend is still supported by impressive cash flows. Further, the management team still expects annual dividend growth to fall into the 3-5% range. Indeed, a 3% hike isn’t much, but given the headwinds, I’d argue that any such hike should be applauded by TFSA investors.

The bottom line

At the end of the day, TRP stock is a dividend juggernaut. And if it can escape its funk, contrarian investors may be able to lock in the dividend yield alongside potentially juicy capital gains in a recovery.

Is TC Energy a risky play at this juncture?

Definitely. But the potential rewards justify the risks for most TFSA investors, in my opinion.

If you’re an older investor, however, GICs may be the better bet while rates are high.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

gold prices rise and fall
Tech Stocks

The Only 3 Stocks I’d Consider Buying in March 2026

March 2026 presents unique stock opportunities amid AI spending and geopolitical tensions. Learn which stocks to watch.

Read more »

RRSP (Registered Retirement Savings Plan) on wooden blocks and Canadian one hundred dollar bills.
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks I’d Buy and Never Sell in an RRSP

Enbridge (TSX:ENB) stock and other proven dividend heavyweights to keep holding as a part of a top-notch RRSP income portfolio.

Read more »

Couple working on laptops at home and fist bumping
Dividend Stocks

1 Dividend Great I’d Buy Over Telus or BCE Stock Today

Explore the impact of regulations on BCE's and Telus's dividends. Here is a better dividend alternative for investors.

Read more »

dividend stocks are a good way to earn passive income
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks for Canadian Investors to Hold Through Retirement

These companies have increased their dividends annually for decades.

Read more »

slow sloth in Costa Rica
Dividend Stocks

2 No-Brainer Dividend Stocks to Buy Hand Over Fist

Cargojet and Spin Master are two dividend stocks built for long-term growth. Here's why Canadian investors should consider buying both…

Read more »

dividend stocks bring in passive income so investors can sit back and relax
Investing

The Best Stocks to Buy With $1,000 Right Now

If you have $1,000 sitting on the sidelines, the current volatility in the TSX is the opportunity you’ve been waiting…

Read more »

young adult uses credit card to shop online
Dividend Stocks

3 Stocks to Double Up on Right Now

These three top Canadian stocks could double your investment in the years to come with their strong fundamentals, reliable dividends,…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Investing

Your 2026 TFSA Game Plan: How to Turn the Contribution Room Into Monthly Cash

This TFSA strategy helps reduce risk while providing a decent yield.

Read more »