I Was Wrong: S&P 500 ETFs Are Risky. This One Is Far Superior

The S&P 500 hit US$5,000 highs, but is now incredibly risky with over exposure to the Magnificent Seven. I’d get in on another ETF instead.

| More on:

There has long been one piece of advice provided by Warren Buffett: if you’re a nervous investor, invest long term in S&P 500 Index exchange-traded funds (ETFs) with low management fees.

But right now, that’s simply something I wouldn’t do.

These ETFs have become too risky given one factor. Today, we’re going to look at what that factor is and where investors may want to start investing instead.

Heavy on Big Tech

The market rally on the S&P 500 has seen shares climb past the US$5,000 mark already in 2024. Yet this rally could be seen as coming down to just a few stocks. And those stocks are the Magnificent Seven. These are companies you know, including Meta, Apple, Alphabet and more. This has made the index top-heavy, with smaller companies perhaps not doing as well.

The recent rally marked the 14th week of jumps in the last 15 weeks — something investors haven’t seen in over 50 years. The Index is now at the highest level investors have seen since the 1970s. And sure, those heavy hitters have proven to be quite valuable. Yet some have shown that they aren’t immune to market drops.

About half of the Big Tech firms so far saw a drop in share price, even when they didn’t announce earnings that missed estimates. And given they make up almost 30% of the S&P 500 and its market cap, that’s quite significant. And sure, earnings have proven strong. But the market is fickle, as we’ve seen. Shares could just as easily drop should we get more bad news on macro issues like interest rates and inflation.

Historically, big isn’t best

The largest stocks tend to actually do worse over time than their smaller counterparts, according to research by GMO Investment and Asset Management. Historically, the top 10 stocks tend to become expensive, and then when investors see value isn’t there anymore, they see a sharp drop in returns.

This adds up over time. Since 1957, the top 10 largest companies on the S&P 500 have actually underperformed the rest of the Index. And this could only become worse, given that in recent history, we’ve seen even more concentration.

You might be thinking I’m crazy, thinking that betting against these big tech stocks in 2023 would have been disastrous. And you’re right! But today, it’s a different situation, and that situation is a return to normalcy — a normalcy that, overall, could see the larger companies swell and decline. So, where might investors want to go instead?

Get on another index

If you’re a long-term holder and bought the S&P 500 at lower levels, then by all means, continue to hold. Or even better, consider selling and buying on another dip. But if you’re hoping to buy now and see similar growth from the last year, I wouldn’t hold your breath.

Instead, now is a great time to get in on a rally among other companies. And for that, I would look to ETFs that focus on the Russell 2000. In fact, analysts believe that the Russell 2000 is now primed for a breakout, with shares up 22% since bottoming out last year. And this earnings season, the Index has seen companies overall perform better as more than 80% of companies reporting thus far have beat estimates.

What’s more, the Russell 2000 doesn’t have the focus on the Magnificent Seven, compared to the S&P 500. So, overall, you’ll be getting a better deal and likely better performance. Therefore, it might be time to consider a Russell 2000 ETF, one such as iShares U.S. Small Cap Index ETF (CAD-Hedged) (TSX:XSU). This allows for exposure to the rally in United States stocks but is far more diversified. It seeks to track the Russell 2000, providing a 1.14% dividend as well!

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Randi Zuckerberg, a former director of market development and spokeswoman for Facebook and sister to Meta Platforms CEO Mark Zuckerberg, is a member of The Motley Fool's board of directors. Suzanne Frey, an executive at Alphabet, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Alphabet, Apple, and Meta Platforms. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

engineer at wind farm
Energy Stocks

Invest $20,000 in This Dividend Stock for $100 in Monthly Passive Income

This dividend stock has it all – a strong outlook, monthly income, and even more to consider buying today.

Read more »

stocks climbing green bull market
Stocks for Beginners

3 TSX Stocks Soaring Higher With No Signs of Slowing

Don't ignore stocks just because they look like they're at a high price. Instead, see exactly why they've driven so…

Read more »

Middle aged man drinks coffee
Dividend Stocks

Here’s the Average TFSA Balance at Age 35 in Canada

At age 35, it might not seem like you need to be thinking about your future cash flow. But ideally,…

Read more »

a man relaxes with his feet on a pile of books
Dividend Stocks

CPP Pensioners: Watch for These Important Updates

The CPP is an excellent tool for retirees, but be sure to stay on top of important updates like these.

Read more »

Piggy bank with word TFSA for tax-free savings accounts.
Stocks for Beginners

2 Top TSX Growth Stocks to Stash in a TFSA for Life

These two growth stocks may not be the top in the last month, but in the last few years, they…

Read more »

people relax on mountain ledge
Dividend Stocks

Invest $10,000 in This Dividend Stock for a Potential $4,781.70 in Total Returns

A dividend stock doesn't have to be risky, or without growth. And in the case of this one, the growth…

Read more »

TFSA (Tax free savings account) acronym on wooden cubes on the background of stacks of coins
Dividend Stocks

How to Turn a $15,000 TFSA Into $171,000

$15,000 may not seem like a lot, but over time that amount can balloon into serious cash.

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Stocks for Beginners

Why I’d Buy Fairfax Financial Stock Even at Today’s Prices

Fairfax stock just keeps edging higher. But is it now too expensive, or can investors just look forward to even…

Read more »