TFSA Red Flags: These Canadians Broke the Rules and Got Taxed

Holding funds like the Vanguard FTSE All-Cap Canada ETF (TSX:VCN) in a TFSA beats day trading.

| More on:
Man looks stunned about something

Source: Getty Images

Breaking your tax-free savings account (TFSA) account rules is a great way to be taxed when you least expect it. We expect TFSA returns to be tax-free – it’s in the account’s name after all – but if we play fast and loose with the rules, we may end up being taxed on TFSA holdings.

In this article, I share the stories of three Canadians who violated TFSA account rules and got taxed on their holdings. I will keep the individuals’ names anonymous; you can find more details on their stories by Googling keywords from the short stories below. I’ll also provide some advice on how to avoid their fate(s).

Case #1: Woman uses swaps to turn $5,000 into $200,000 – gets taxed

In 2019, a woman lost her appeal after the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) taxed her TFSA for day trading and she challenged the tax bill. What this individual did was use swaps to turn a $5,000 TFSA into a $200,000 nest egg. She was found to have been carrying out business activities in her TFSA and was taxed accordingly. The fact that she challenged the CRA in court and lost illustrates the authority’s attitude toward Canadians using swaps and other derivatives to achieve outsized TFSA profits. Basically, it’s not friendly towards them.

Case #2: Redditor over-contributes

Last year, an anonymous Canadian took to Reddit to share his story of having over-contributed to his TFSA in 2023. He calculated his over-contribution penalty at $30 and stated that he intended to pay it. This individual may have some luck getting the taxes waived by the CRA if he reports the situation promptly. However, more serious and long-term cases of over-contribution can result in significant penalties.

Case #3: Former trader amasses $1.25 million TFSA – CRA comes knocking

In 2015, the Financial Post reported the story of a former professional trader who reached a $1.25 million TFSA balance. The CRA found out about about it and decided that he was on the hook for taxes. Like the person in case #1, this individual challenged the CRA in court and lost on appeal.

What to do about it

If you have a large TFSA balance, there are three things you can do to protect your account from taxation:

  1. Do not over-contribute. Stay within your contribution limit; you can find it on CRA MyAccount.
  2. If you’re self-employed, don’t try to turn your business into a security and deposit the security in your TFSA. This is a surefire way to get taxed.
  3. Do not day trade in your TFSA, especially not full time using expensive research services and trading software.

The last item on the list above is especially worth noting. Day trading full time in a TFSA can result in some very steep taxes. Of the three cases discussed above, it was day traders/options traders who got hit with the biggest taxes; the over-contributor paid a mere $30 penalty.

Instead of day trading in your TFSA, you should passively invest in low cost ETFs like the Vanguard FTSE All-Cap Canada ETF (TSX:VCN). VCN is an ultra-diversified ETF that tracks 98% of the Canadian stock market. Its universe of stocks is quite large (161), though smaller than that of a TSX index funds (220). Its management fee and management expense ratio are both 0.05%, which is fairly low. And finally, the fund is fairly liquid with a small bid-ask spread. Overall, it’s a great passive fund to consider. Certainly, it beats day trading in your TFSA.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Andrew Button has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

data analyze research
Dividend Stocks

Better Stock to Buy Now: Manulife or CIBC?

Both Manulife and CIBC had a great year last year. It may be smart for investors to wait for a…

Read more »

grow money, wealth build
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Growth Strategy: Turn $350 Weekly Into $100,000

By investing $350 per week in index funds like iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (TSX:XIU) you can achieve a $100,000…

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Dividend Stocks

3 Top Canadian Growth Stocks to Buy Now for Long-Term Growth

Canadian growth stocks can be a great way to create long-term growth, and these are at the top of the…

Read more »

Caution, careful
Dividend Stocks

3 Big Red Flags That Could Trigger a CRA Audit on Your TFSA

TFSA users engaging in business-like activities for profit will trigger a CRA audit.

Read more »

Pile of Canadian dollar bills in various denominations
Dividend Stocks

TD Bank Stock: The Easy Money’s Been Made

After settling with US regulators, this Canadian bank stock should at least market perform, but should you buy more shares?

Read more »

Silver coins fall into a piggy bank.
Investing

Want Safe Dividend Income in 2025 and Beyond? Invest in the Following 3 Ultra-High-Yield Stocks

These three TSX royalty trusts pay above-average, steady dividends.

Read more »

grow money, wealth build
Dividend Stocks

3 Top Canadian Stocks to Buy for Dividend Growth

Discover three outstanding Canadian dividend-growth stocks that have consistently delivered double-digit payout increases, fueling income growth for long-term investors.

Read more »

Canadian Dollars bills
Dividend Stocks

Invest $50,000 in This Stock and Get $2,950 Back Per Year in Dividends

First National Financial (TSX:FN) stock throws off a lot of income.

Read more »