Better Retail Stock: Dollarama vs Canadian Tire?

These two growth stocks are some of the best retail stocks in Canada, but which is the better buy?

| More on:
Confused person shrugging

Source: Getty Images

When Canadian investors set their sights on retail stocks, there’s a smorgasbord of factors to chew over. First and foremost, it’s essential to delve into the company’s financial health. This means poring over balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow reports to ensure the retailer isn’t teetering on the edge of insolvency. A robust financial foundation often signals a company’s resilience in the ever-fluctuating retail landscape. Yet there’s even more to consider, especially when looking at two titans of the industry. So let’s take a deep dive.

What to watch

Beyond financial health, market position and brand strength play pivotal roles. A retail stock with a sterling reputation and a loyal customer base is more likely to weather economic storms. Furthermore, growth prospects are another critical consideration. Investors should assess the company’s plans for expansion, whether through opening new stores, entering untapped markets, or diversifying product lines. A retail stock with a clear and achievable growth strategy often presents a more enticing investment opportunity.

Let’s not forget about the competitive landscape. Understanding who the main rivals are and how the company differentiates itself is crucial. Does it offer unique products or superior customer service? Standing out in a crowded market can be the difference between thriving and merely surviving.

Economic factors also come into play. Retailers are particularly sensitive to changes in consumer spending. This can be influenced by interest rates, employment levels, and overall economic health. Keeping an eye on these macroeconomic indicators can provide insight into potential headwinds or tailwinds for the retail sector.

Dollarama

Now let’s turn our attention to two Canadian retail giants, Dollarama (TSX:DOL) and Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A). Both have carved out significant niches in the market, but which one offers a more compelling investment case?

Dollarama, the discount retail behemoth, has been on a tear in recent years. As of its latest earnings report, the retail stock boasted a market capitalization of approximately $40.7 billion. Its trailing twelve months (TTM) revenue stood at $6.1 billion, with a net income of $1.1 billion, reflecting a profit margin of 17.9%. The company’s return on equity (ROE) is particularly striking at 156.5%, indicating exceptional efficiency in generating profits from shareholders’ equity.

In its third-quarter report, Dollarama’s net sales rose by 5.7% to $1.6 billion, while net earnings per share increased by 6.5% to $0.98. This growth underscores the company’s ability to attract price-conscious consumers, especially in an environment where shoppers are seeking value deals.

Canadian Tire

On the flipside, Canadian Tire offers a more diversified retail experience, encompassing automotive, living, seasonal, and gardening segments. As of its latest earnings, the retail stock had a market capitalization of around $9.2 billion. Its TTM revenue was $16.3 billion, with a net income of $648.7 million, resulting in a profit margin of 4%. The ROE for Canadian Tire stands at 11.2% which, while respectable, pales in comparison to Dollarama’s.

In the second quarter of 2024, Canadian Tire reported earnings of $198.8 million, or $3.56 per diluted share, up from $99.4 million the previous year. This rebound indicates a positive trajectory, although the company’s profit margins remain slimmer than Dollarama’s.

Bottom line

Looking ahead, Dollarama’s aggressive expansion plans, including a target of 2,000 stores by 2031 and a growing presence in Latin America through its Dollarcity partnership, position it as a growth-oriented investment. The retail stock’s focus on affordable essentials makes it particularly appealing during economic downturns when consumers tighten their belts.

Canadian Tire, with its broad product categories and established brand, offers stability and a steady dividend yield. The company’s diversified offerings provide a buffer against sector-specific downturns, and its commitment to returning value to shareholders through dividends makes it attractive to income-focused investors.

In conclusion, if you’re seeking growth and are comfortable with a higher valuation, Dollarama presents a compelling case. Its impressive profit margins, high ROE, and ambitious expansion plans highlight its potential for continued success. Conversely, if stability and dividends are more your speed, Canadian Tire’s diversified portfolio and consistent dividend payouts make it a solid choice. As always, aligning your investment with your financial goals and risk tolerance is paramount.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

jar with coins and plant
Dividend Stocks

1 Incredibly Cheap Canadian Dividend-Growth Stock to Buy Now and Hold for Decades

Finding an undervalued stock is great, sure. But when it's in this high-growth area with a dividend, it's perfection!

Read more »

Skiier goes down the mountain on a sunny day
Tech Stocks

Meet the Canadian Stock That Continues to Crush the Market 

It's normal to beat the market once or twice while riding a trend. But this stock has been crushing the…

Read more »

Hourglass and stock price chart
Tech Stocks

2 Brilliant Growth Stocks to Buy Now and Hold for the Long Term

Growth stocks are amazing, but only when they have a true growth outlook. Luckily, these two match right up.

Read more »

Tech Stocks

Why I’m Bearish on Celestica Stock, and What I’m Buying Instead

Celestica stock has exploded in share price, but the future doesn't look as certain. So why not consider this stock…

Read more »

A doctor takes a patient's blood pressure in a clinical office.
Stocks for Beginners

This Healthcare Stock Could Be the Best Investment of the Decade

Healthcare will always be around. But tech is just beginning. Why not mix them both together?

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Dividend Stocks

2 High-Dividend TSX Stocks to Buy for Increasing Payouts

Let's grab some high growth and solid dividends with these two top TSX stocks.

Read more »

Income and growth financial chart
Stocks for Beginners

These 2 TSX Stocks Are Set to Soar in 2025 and Beyond

Consistently growing demand for their products and services could help these two TSX stocks rally in the coming years.

Read more »

The TFSA is a powerful savings vehicle for Canadians who are saving for retirement.
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian ETFs to Buy and Hold Forever in Your TFSA

These three ETFs are some of the top choices for a TFSA, so let's get started.

Read more »