Better Stock to Buy Now: Manulife or CIBC?

Both Manulife and CIBC had a great year last year. It may be smart for investors to wait for a pullback in the shares.

| More on:
data analyze research

Image source: Getty Images

Over the past year, both Manulife Financial (TSX:MFC) and Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX:CM) have posted impressive returns of around 55%. While these gains are certainly exciting, investors should keep in mind that such high returns are unlikely to repeat in the near future. So, which stock is the better choice for today’s market: Manulife or CIBC? Let’s dive in and break it down.

Manulife: A solid bet with room to grow

Manulife stock has been on an upward trajectory after a prolonged period of sideways trading. From 2015 through late 2023, the stock essentially moved within a sideways range. However, as the company earnings slowly grew over time, the stock finally broke out in late 2023 — a classic case of valuation reverting to the mean.

Manulife’s adjusted earnings per share (EPS) over the past decade had been a strong compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 10%. Before its recent rally, the stock was trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of just eight, making it cheap relative to its earnings growth. Now, at around $43.81 per share at writing, the stock still offers a P/E ratio of approximately 11.5, which remains reasonable given its consistent earnings growth.

In addition to its growth potential, Manulife’s dividend yield is decent, currently sitting at about 3.7%. The company maintains a payout ratio of around 42% of adjusted earnings, suggesting the dividend is sustainable. Over the past decade, Manulife has increased its dividend at an annual growth rate of 10.9%, and the most recent hike of 9.6% further underscores its commitment to returning value to shareholders.

CIBC: A blue-chip bank that rebounded strongly

CIBC had a rough patch in 2022 due to the impact of rising interest rates at the time. The bank experienced a mild earnings decline in both fiscal 2022 and 2023, which weighed heavily on the stock. In October 2023, the stock hit a low point of around $49 per share, trading at a P/E of just 7.2, a level that many saw as too cheap to ignore.

Since then, CIBC’s stock has rebounded sharply, up approximately 86%, driven by a strong 10% growth in adjusted EPS for fiscal 2024. At $91.20 per share at writing, the stock now offers a dividend yield of nearly 4.3%. The bank recently raised its quarterly dividend by 7.8%, signalling confidence in its future earnings. With a payout ratio of about 50%, the dividend appears to be well-covered and sustainable.

Although the stock has rebounded strongly, CIBC now trades at a higher valuation compared to its historical levels. Analysts consider the stock to be fairly valued, but it doesn’t offer much margin of safety.

The Foolish investor takeaway: Which stock offers better value?

Both Manulife and CIBC have delivered solid returns over the past year, but it’s important for investors to exercise caution moving forward. Both stocks have likely priced in much of their near-term growth, and chasing gains could be risky.

Between the two, Manulife may offer greater value at its current price, given its solid earnings growth history, nice dividend yield, and, most importantly, still-reasonable valuation. CIBC, while a strong rebound story, has already seen significant upside, making it potentially less attractive at this point. For those looking for a balance of growth and income, Manulife could be the better pick — especially if you can catch it during a market pullback. Regardless, patience is key; waiting for a dip may be the smartest strategy for buying either stock at a more favourable price.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

A worker gives a business presentation.
Dividend Stocks

Billionaires Are Selling Netflix Stock and Buying a Top TSX Stock Right Now

Netflix stock continues to show signs of strength, but there are some weaknesses, which might be why billionaires are switching…

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Dividend Stocks

Invest $3,000 in This Dividend Stock for $216.45 in Passive Income

This dividend stock can provide investors with $18 per month from dividends alone! But there are even more reasons to…

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Dividend Growers Set to Boost Payouts in 2025

Are you worried about stock market volatility. Own these quality Canadian dividend growers for a rising stream of passive income.

Read more »

An investor uses a tablet
Dividend Stocks

A Dividend Powerhouse to Buy Over Enbridge Stock Right Now

Enbridge stock has long been a fan favourite for dividends, but this one looks more valuable.

Read more »

Hand Protecting Senior Couple
Dividend Stocks

3 High-Yield Stocks for Canadian Retirees

With a reliable payout history, solid dividend growth, and high yields, these TSX stocks are compelling investment for retirees.

Read more »

Paper Canadian currency of various denominations
Dividend Stocks

My Top Monthly Dividend Stocks for Passive Income

These stocks offer monthly dividends and high yields, making them top investments to generate solid passive income.

Read more »

chart reflected in eyeglass lenses
Dividend Stocks

This 5.2% TSX Dividend Stock Pays Cash Every Single Month

Down almost 15% from all-time highs, Exchange Income is a TSX dividend stock that trades at sizeable discount to price…

Read more »

Canadian dollars in a magnifying glass
Dividend Stocks

The Best Canadian Stocks to Buy Right Away With $30,000

When it comes to choosing the right Canadian stocks, these three are no-brainer buys for any portfolio.

Read more »